2 thoughts on “American Tourister Luggage Fieldbrook II 3 Part Set, Ebony

  1. Dear_Child
    167 of 178 people found the following review helpful
    2.0 out of 5 stars
    Not made for the long haul, December 16, 2015
    By 

    Verified Purchase(What’s this?)
    Mine looked just like they do in the image, however I seem to have gotten the lower quality/rip off version that another reviewer spoke of. First I opened the main compartment of the largest case, the zipper opened smoothly but the positives stop there. The “lining” of the main compartment was just a loosely fitting bit of fabric held on with dots of velcro in each corner that looked to me like the mere movement of clothes would dislodge them – completely defeating the purpose of the lining. The lining fabric itself felt, and sounded more like paper than fabric, this applied to the linings in the main compartment and the two front pockets. When I tested the pull out handle it was wobbly and felt flimsy to the touch. The back panel of the case was thin and looked a bit loose. I didn’t even bother opening the rest of the cases after that. I was looking for something a little more long term and as it is, this set is not it for me.

    UPDATE: 01/14/2016
    I realized that I didn’t post any of the pictures I took so I’ll be putting them up now.
    You can see the fabric puckering on the back in the second picture. The third picture shows how the rough sides are exposed to the clothing. The fourth is the “lining” turned up to show how it was fastened. And the last one shows the seaming next to one of the corners.

    Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 

    Was this review helpful to you? Yes
    No

    Reply
  2. Siberia2k
    53 of 55 people found the following review helpful
    4.0 out of 5 stars
    To correct the reviewers complaining about getting a cheaper version and for a real review., August 12, 2016
    By 

    Verified Purchase(What’s this?)
    This review is from: American Tourister Luggage Fieldbrook II 3 Piece Set (Apparel)
    I never write reviews, but I have to in this case because there are others who don’t know what they are talking about with regard to American Touristers product lines. I’ve read a few reviews that claim they got “stuck with a counterfeit or a cheaper version” of the product that they ordered; nonsense, they just don’t know what they are talking about. There are 2 very similar looking product lines, this one the FIELDBROOK (again the product that I’m reviewing now) and the upscale (and costing twice as much) BROOKFIELD line. Both products look very similar but the BROOKFIELD has a more finished look, the inside is lined better and has 4 swivel wheels. The FIELDBROOK (again the product this review is actually for) is half the cost of the BROOKFIELD, is semi lined and has 2 fixed inline wheels. I have to assume they ordered the FIELDBROOK and are confusing it with it’s higher priced sibling the BROOKFIELD thus making their reviews somewhat null.

    Now for a review of the FIELDBROOK line here we go.

    It’s cheap luggage, it doesn’t have all the bells and whistles like swivel wheels; so you can’t put the two larger cases back to back and just push along or change direction as quickly. Also, along with having to pull the bags, you will have to deal with the weight of the bags hanging on your arms, but for the vast majority this is of little concern for the amount of time we’re pulling this along when compared to the price. The entire thing is made out of polyester and plastics, the inside finish is ok but Spartan. This line is the base product line, it’s like a Toyota Yaris, not the Avalon.

    I’ve had a FIELDBROOK set for 10 years and gone everywhere with them. I’m only replacing now as the old ones were frayingpilling a little on the outside, the wheels are worn down to nubs and the airline broke the handle off the larger case on my last trip. The differences I see between the 10 year old bags and these are the older large bag was 24″ vs the new one at 25″. The older bags have a reinforcing strap running the entire way around the outside and the new ones don’t. Finally the new ones have a better, more sturdy looking foot (2 wheels and a plastic foot to balance on when upright)

    I gave it 4 stars because these are good, decent luggage, but they aren’t perfect. If your looking for perfect, with all the options then be willing to spend some real money

    Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 

    Was this review helpful to you? Yes
    No

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *